Sunday, 21 June 2020

WE (THE PEOPLE) VS THEM (THE PUBLIC SERVANTS)


A few days back I received two messages through WhatsApp from an activist friend of mine.  One of them was about the ordinary folks’ penchant for cheap stuff, even in the matter of food stuffs which may be injurious to their health. He was mentioning specifically about coconut oil. He has a coconut farm and he says that it costs Rs 250/- to market a kilogram of pure coconut oil. He laments that people would prefer to buy adulterated coconut oil at Rs 225/- per kg and ruin their health than go for the pure variety which was good for health.

I recollected my own intervention in the matter of 6 lakh kgs of pepper that had been ordered to be burnt by the Food Safety Commissioner (FSC) of Kerala because it had been colored with mineral oil and polished with paraffin wax, both known to be cancerogenous. Almost four years later it was reported that the pepper was to be cleaned under the supervision of the Food Safety Commissioner.

On pursuing under the Right to Information Act, the following facts were revealed. One, the order for cleaning the adulterated pepper had been given by a single judge bench of the Kerala High Court. Two, the FSC had identified a caffeine processing plant in Palakkad as the only facility for this cleaning. Three, the cleaning was done by washing with detergent followed by rinsing with clean water.

The information not provided include, the copies of test results that made the FSC order the burning of 6 lakh kgs of pepper in the first place and the test results after the cleaning.

The last that was heard about the cleaned pepper was that it was found unsuitable for export and hence would be sold in the local market itself.

This episode can be closed with two questions: one, does pepper that is unfit for consumption by foreigners become fit for consumption by locals? Two, can the spices be removed from pickled vegetables by washing with detergent and rinsing with clean water?

Coming to the second question, which should rightly be answered by the judge of the Kerala High Court who ordered the cleaning of the pepper, there is another case that comes to mind.

In the matter of the Hindustan Coca Cola Beverages Ltd (Coca Cola Company, for short) which was accused of overdrawing the underground water at Plachimada, a single judge bench of Kerala High Court had ruled that the company could not overdraw ground water as it would lead to water scarcity in the neighborhood. A division bench of the same high court later ruled in favor of the company stating that the right of a company to draw water from its property even for commercial uses is the same as the right of an individual to draw water from his property for personal consumption.

Back to my activist friend and his second message.

Here he has openly warned other activists from interfering with illegal mining mafia saying that they should be prepared for being framed in false cases by the police working in nexus with such mafia as well as being assaulted by the goons of such mafia while the police looked the other way.

Here also I have my own experience to narrate.
It happened more than decade back. Somebody from the outskirts of my town informed of an illegal quarry working in his neighborhood causing damages to the houses there and pollution too. He had informed me that he had complained to the local Kasaba Police and to the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO). After visiting the site with him I pursued a few applications under the RTI Act.

The RDO informed me that the matter had been reported to the Mining and Geology Office in the district. This office informed me that their officials had visited the site and, finding the quarrying illegal, had directed the police to take necessary action. The police informed me that they had never received any complaints.

As facts stood it was the responsibility of the Mining and Geology Department to prosecute the offenders. Even the RDO could have punished them within his powers.

However, even though no one was learnt to have been punished, the quarrying had been stopped eventually. I too had then got a veiled threat from the mafia which I could only dismiss with the contempt it deserved.

Activists, I must say, are among the best citizens in any democracy. Not just because I consider myself to be one. Knowledgeable people have said that alert citizens are essential for the success of any democracy. Also, that eternal vigilance is the price of liberty. So, it comes as no surprise that activists are persona non grata for our so-called public servants who have continued to live in the inherited dream world of our colonial past. But the misfortune is that it is not only activists who are kababi ki haddi for our public servants. Just to prove this point here is the story of Krisna, a farm laborer, on social security pension, who got bitten by a stray dog and his fight for being compensated.

Krisna was sitting in front of his hut when a stray dog rushed in and gave a bite. He was rushed to the District Hospital where they did not have the anti-rabies serum for injection. He went to the medical college where they got him to buy the serum from a private pharmacy for about Rs 14,000/-.

On the advice of a friendly neighborhood activist (FNA) he sent a demand for reimbursement of the cost of medicine to the office of State’s Health Minister. Soon he got an intimation that the claim had been forwarded to the District Medical Officer (DMO) for necessary action. He was glad that he would soon receive the reimbursement. But he was disappointed as there was no response from the DMO’s office.

Guided by the FNA, he applied under the Right to Information (RTI) Act to the DMO’s office to find out what action had been taken on the letter from the Health Minister’s office. To his horror he was informed that they had not received any such letter.

He submitted an appeal to the DMO’s office. They wrote back asking him to provide a copy of his application and the reply by their Public Information Officer. Since these documents were available in their office, Krisna submitted the next appeal to the State’s Information Commission. This was dismissed. Arbitrarily, no doubt.

Krisna then applied under the RTI Act to the minister’s office, seeking to know the details of the posting of the letter to the DMO’s office and also of any reply received from the latter. No response was received. A complaint to the Information Commission was also arbitrarily dismissed.

Persevering, with the support of the FNA of course, Krisna complained to the District Collector. It got routed to the DMO, District Hospital and finally to the Medical College, with nothing useful coming out of the effort.

It was around that time that the then Chief Minister, Ommen Chandy, decided to hold one of his Public Contact Programs in the district. The modus operandi was the citizens could submit their complaints or applications to the District Collector, who in turn would route them to the concerned public servants. On the day of the Contact Program all public authorities would set up their stalls and through these stalls the replies to the complaints would be distributed. Those who were not satisfied with the reply could meet the CM.

Krisna’s complaint was routed to the Tehsildar and he was told to contact their office the next working day. Not knowing what to do he decided to meet the CM. He did not get the opportunity. The next day’s media reports announced how the CM left the venue late at night after seeing the last citizen who had wanted to meet him.

Krisna went to the Tehsildar’s office 4-5 times spread over two weeks before he got fed up.

There is quote that goes ‘fortune favors the brave’. May be, it also favors also the persistent.

On a PIL, against the apathy of the government to control stray dog menace, the apex court appointed a one-man judicial committee to inquire into the menace and to suggest compensation to the victims.

Krisna approached the Committee through an NGO. Two years later, and 7 years after his initial application to the Health Minister, the Municipality paid him about Rs 47,000/- on the direction of the Committee.

Tailpiece: This is one of the rare judicial committees whose reports have been acted upon. This committee which was constituted as per order dated 05/04/2016 in IA 4/2015 in WP (C) 599/2015, was known to be functional even as on 20/04/2019. Since there are no media reports on the activities of the Committee it is not known whether it is continuing even now or not. But there are plenty of stray dog bite cases being reported in the media.


29/05/2020


P M Ravindran; raviforjustice@gmail.com

KOLLUNNA RAAJAAVINU THINNUNNA MANTHRI


The above quip, For the king who kills, The minister who eats, conveys the modus operandi of a team that commits a crime and leaves no trace of it. Such a crime manifested in Kerala during the Covid lockdown. Kerala is the only State where the Communist Party of India (Marxist) is in power. There have been rave reviews, even at the international level, on the way this government has managed the pandemic problem in the State. These are mainly the work of “embedded” journalists far removed from ground realities. Of course, the whole country is fighting Covid. Under these circumstances, the Sprinklr (no ‘e’) controversy has played out in Kerala.

Sprinklr is a Keralite-owned, US based company that claims to be an expert in data analysis. They approached the Government of Kerala and offered to help with the analysis of data of those affected by Covid and whose details were included in the data base of the government. It was a free of cost offer and on that count beyond reproach. But cyberspace has it that the cost of such data of even an individual varies from Rs 15,000/- to Rs 1,50,000/- among pharma companies. And the data with the State Government ran into a couple of lakhs.

The controversy erupted when a journalist asked the Chief Minister, during his then regular 6 p.m. briefings on the Covid situation, why a foreign firm had been entrusted this job and how the personal information was transferred to a private firm. The Chief Minister initially defended it on the irrelevant ground that it was free and there was no loss to the government. But soon he lost his cool and called off the briefing. The briefings stood cancelled for the next few days.

The briefings were resumed only after Secretary of the Information Technology Dept., of which the Chief Minister is in-charge, admitted that he was responsible for the deal in all its aspects and that he had not even deemed it necessary to approach the Law Department for advice. Of course, he must have been reassured that the Chief Minister would not permit his prosecution.

The matter reached the High Court of Kerala which pulled up the Government for failure to follow procedures and directed them to recall the data already uploaded to Sprinklr’s website and give it back to them after hiding the personal identifiers. A great decision indeed, for the layman. For those better informed about technology, it is stupid.

Meanwhile, the Government constituted a committee of two former bureaucrats to probe the matter. Rajeev Sadanand, a member of the committee, was Health Secretary during the Oommen Chandy government in 2012. The UDF Government had then ordered a study, the Kerala Health Observatory Baseline Study (KHOBS), to be done along with a Canadian firm, Population Health Research institute. The study was stopped when the opposition, then headed by Pinayari Vijayan of the CPI(M), alleged data leak.

When Pinayari Vijayan became Chief Minister in 2016, Rajeev Sadanand pushed the same study, with the same Canadian partners, under the name, Epidemiological Surveillance. This was also given up when it became a controversy. But not one to give up, Sadanand initiated a move to compile the health data of about 10 lakh citizens, with their permission, over a 10-year period. This project, KIRAN (Kerala Information on Residents-Arogyam Network) was to be executed with the help of the Achutha Menon Centre for Medical Science and Technology of Sri Chitra Institute, Thiruvananthapuram. But then, information leaked out that it was the directors of the Canadian company who were funding the survey. Questions asked had no responses.

Rajeev Sadanand is also under suspicion of trying to favor two medical colleges that had been denied permission by courts to admit students for their MBBS course. Need one say more where the report of this committee will lead to?

Cyberspace is rife with speculation regarding the involvement of the Chief Minister’s daughter, T. Veena, in the deal. She is the MD of Bangalore-based IT firm Exalogic Solutions Pvt. Ltd., with an investment of Rs 100 crore. This company does business in the same field as Sprinklr. Further indictment came when it was reported that in the registration documents of the company, the address of the owner is given as AKG Centre, Thiruvananthapuram, and the nominee is Kamala Vijayan, wife of Pinayari Vijayan; her address was given as that of Pinayari Vijayan’s house at Thalassery. Earlier, media reports stated that during the last nation-wide strike, the company had a regular working day when Kerala was under a lockdown.

As Chief Minister, Pinayari Vijayan has made many foreign trips to seek investment in Kerala, particularly from Non-Resident Keralites. This brings me to the case of Dr. Jacob Thomas, the senior most serving member of the IPS in the State and currently MD of Metal Industries, Shornur, a Government of Kerala undertaking. The firm manufactures spades, pick axes, shovels etc. It has four officers and 36 employees, besides the MD. The salary of the senior most officer, the Works Manager, was Rs 43,890/- as on November 15, 2019.

Dr. Jacob Thomas invited the wrath of the IAS lobby after he sought permission to prosecute some of them as Director, Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau. The lobby tried its best to get him removed, but Pinayari Vijayan was in no mood to relent. The lobby threatened to go on mass casual leave. The Chief Minister called them and, according to a report in Mathrubhumi daily, said he had withheld sanction to prosecute the then Chief Secretary, K.M. Abraham, and the then Additional Chief Secretary, Tom Jose (current Chief Secretary, due to retire) in cases of disproportionate assets. He indicated he had protected another Additional Chief Secretary, Paul Antony (without naming him) in a case of nepotism.

The mass casual leave protest collapsed. But indirect pressure tactics continued till Jacob Thomas was shifted to a nondescript organization - Institute of Management in Government. K.M. Abraham retired and has been given a sinecure as ex-officio Secretary of Kerala Infrastructure Investment Fund Board (KIIFB), currently resisting audit by the CAG. Even the compensation offered to him is reportedly in violation of all rules.

The hounding of Jacob Thomas continued with cases initiated against him for saying publicly that the relief work, post the Ockhi typhoon, was not adequate and for publishing a book, ‘Swimming with the Sharks’, without prior permission from the government. He was under suspension for almost 18 months when the Central Administrative Tribunal ordered his reinstatement in an equivalent position. Hence his assignment as MD of Metal Industries with the same status of Director, Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau, through order dated October 5, 2019.

On learning about the above appointment through the media, I complained to the Governor, Kerala, on October 16, 2019, on grounds that thought Dr. Jacob Thomas had accepted this low-level assignment, I am concerned as a citizen at the high cost incurred by the exchequer in granting him a designation, pay and perks, beyond the entitlements of the office he is now serving; and that this is tantamount to abuse of office by the appointing authority. I urged the Governor to ensure that the officer is posted to an office befitting his experience, grade and status, or ensure that his cost to the exchequer does not exceed that of his predecessor. The complaint was forwarded to the General Administration Dept. on December 3, 2019.

Meanwhile, in response to an application under the RTI Act, the Public Information Officer of General Administration Department provided a copy of the Government Order dated October 5, 2019 and nothing more. It mentions Rule 12 of IPS (Pay) Rules, 2016, which are a bundle of contradictions that need to be questioned.

No information was provided regarding the applications seeking prosecution of the three members of the IAS, and the file notes leading to denial of permission. Now, can anybody guess who is the king who kills and the minister who eats in our system of government?

The beauty is that while the king who kills is present all through the narrative, the minister who eats has not appeared at all. Please note that after the minister finishes eating there is (practically) no sign of the crime. Here, so long as evidence exists, the last word can only be that of the judiciary. And it will be the judiciary that will render any evidence irrelevant. 
       06 May 2020
P M Ravindran, raviforjustice@gmail.com

LIFE IN TIMES OF A LOCKOUT


Well, for one who had been daddy sitting for almost 7 years, the lock down is only another name for staying at home. (Not that my dad was sick, or bed ridden. On the other hand, well into his 80s, he was far too active for his age. In a way, even for my age. And that was why I had to be around, to ensure that he did not suffer any fall or such mishap.) After his demise, the only change that had occurred in my routine was an outing for about an hour in the evenings to visit relations or some senior citizens in the neighborhood.  

It was the compulsion that came with the lockdown that made it unpalatable for the first few days. This was so, although it was amply clear that the only way of prevention was to keep social distance. In other words, be with yourself and your family, staying in the same house.

As days dragged on the main obsession was with news on the spread of the virus and the number of casualties- both, who were infected and those who had succumbed.

In Kerala the Chief Minster himself would give out the figures, ensuring that separate figures were mentioned of those who had come with infections from abroad. Piqued by this categorization, an NRI posted a message on social media that the CM should be more circumspect and bear in mind the conditions under which Malayalees were toiling out there to keep their relations here and the State itself economically better off.

The CM had probably taken on the briefing part himself after his Health Minster, who had been doing the briefing earlier, had kept blaming the Center for not doing enough scanning and segregation at the airports.

When lock down was announced apart from essential services, in Kerala, all other government offices were to work with 50 percent attendance every day, with the staff rotating each day. And it was to be a five-day week too.

The Central government offices too were required to work with minimum essential staff. 

But almost a week before the PM announced a three-week national lock down, the apex court had reduced the number of benches from 15 to 6. And when the national lockdown was announced it was reduced to a bench for considering urgent matters. 

We all know that it is only the courts that had been working as per schedules prepared by them, including crowd management (if at all we could call it management) through the number of cases listed for the day. So, there was no rationale in courts doing with namesake benches to deal with ‘urgent’ matters.

How these benches would work also would make one raise one’s eyebrows.

In the apex court, the bench would be in one court room and the advocates in another. The hearing would be conducted through video conferencing.

The Kerala High Court’s designated bench would hold sittings on a few notified days only.

It has been reported that all the cases that had been listed for hearing during the lock down days are being adjourned to Jul 2020, after the summer vacation.

Thankfully, the Supreme Court Bar Association has requested the court to do away with the summer vacation to make up for the lost working days of the court.

The enforcement of the lock down has also invited criticism from some quarters for the way police personnel had resorted to extra-legal methods to punish those who violated the lock down laws. For once, there is a need to condone this because wisdom through the ages tell us that those who are not taught at home to behave will have to learn it at the hands of the public (read police, here).

More importantly the great job done by these public servants, working for more than 12 to 15 hours at a stretch, in delivering food to the needy and assisting the health workers to track and quarantine those who had come into contact with suspected infected persons were a treat to the eyes. There have been reports of these teams facing stiff resistance in some pockets, including being attacked and pelted with stones.

The most heart wrenching scenes during the lockout were of migrant laborers, along with families, trekking back to their native places, hundreds of kilometers away, from Delhi and other cities. The grit amidst helplessness had to be seen to be believed. Some body rightly commented on social media that these poor people never resorted to hurling stones at policemen and security personnel or abusing them. Even their character was emulative when they would only accept the minimum that they needed from those offering food, water and fruits on their way.

The Prime Minister, while announcing the lock down, had clearly requested that the daily wage earners should be looked after by the employers till the situation got back to normal. If only those employers had resorted to paying the advance of their wages for a month and held them back wherever they were, and opted to recover the advance in instalments subsequently, a lot of hardship could have been avoided.

But unlike the migrant laborers, those who congregated at a Nizamuddin mosque created havoc with the national effort to contain the pandemic through social distancing and lock down. Reports indicate that participants of this congregation have been responsible for almost 60 percent of the spurt in cases reported thereafter. Not to mention the herculean task in tracking those who had come into contact with them and quarantining them.

Another alarming report has been of consignments from China being contaminated. It was reported that a few persons of a company in Mysuru, Karnataka who had handled some consignments from China had tested positive. And a couple of European countries too had reported that even the medical stores received from China were found contaminated.

There is this truism that the true worth of a person can be righty gauged only when he is in difficult times. It appears to be true of nations too. One report informed us that a plane loaded with masks, ventilators etc for a European nation was diverted to America because of a higher, cash down payment offered. The only thing missing is the clarity on the role of the US administration in the incidence.

The pandemic has exposed the underbelly of the international organizations like UNO and WHO. Particularly with China heading the UN Security Council on a rotational basis, effort to rake up the issue in the UN has not only failed but WHO is also alleged to be complicit in spreading the virus by relaying too much on the information fed by China only.

The way events have shaped, if somebody believes that it was the trial of a biological weapon gone awry, he cannot be blamed. Now China has also banned research into the origin of this outbreak from Wuhan.

Amidst all these dark clouds, the silver lining is the growth of India as a role model to deal with crises. Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s call to his fellow countrymen to thank the Covid warriors by lighting a lamp or candle for 9 minutes at 9 PM on 5th April was not only received with great aplomb by Indians, in India, it was welcomed equally well by people in Australia, UK, US of A and many more countries, large and small.

There have been reports also of Japan setting up a fund to persuade its companies in China to shift, back to Japan or anywhere else. The chances of many of them shifting to India are good. Such moves can be expected from many of the European and American establishments also.

And, yes, some body has rightly pointed out that India is now a pharmacy for the world. The demand of Hydroxychloroquine by the US of A, for which the President of the US had made a direct request to our Prime Minister, is indeed gratifying.

Unfortunately, there were unwarranted controversies raked up by the media who reported that Trump had threatened India with retaliation and Modi succumbed to it.

But then, media apart, there are many in this country whose only agenda seems to be belittling the nation and it elected leader, Narendra Damodardas Modi. This Covid season seems to establish not only Narendra Modi as a world leader but also this nation as a wonder, defeating a pandemic stoically amidst a lot of poverty.

The predictions from Nostradamus to Einstein are being recollected, of India’s rise to leadership among world’s nations. Something we can all be proud of and help to cheer us in these days of gloom.




P M Ravindran, raviforjustice@gmail.com

14 Apr 2020

Sunday, 12 April 2020

INDIA- A DEMOCRACY OR KRYTOCRACY?

INDIA- A DEMOCRACY OR KRYTOCRACY? 
P M Ravindran, raviforjustice@gmail.com 

Let me begin by answering the above question bluntly- India is a Krytocracy (also spelt as kritocracy) and an unacceptable one at that.

On 03 Mar 2020 there was a cryptic report in the Janmabhumi Daily that I came across. It shared the concern of the Chief Justice of India, Mr S A Bobde, on how the judiciary was stressed by media reports criticizing the judiciary. It was made in the context of an advocate arguing for considering the petitions, against some allegedly inflammatory speeches made by some BJP leaders, on priority. The CJI had also gone on to remark that the judiciary does not have any control over events when it was happening, and it could intervene only once the event is over.

I was reminded of old time movies where the police arrived on the scene just immediately after the hero had bundled up the villains, read criminals, whom he had fought throughout the movie single handedly, or may be with a Sancho Panza by his side. 

The same day, The Indian Express had carried an article by an advocate, Dushyant Dave (https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/delhi-riots-high-court-fir-kapil-mishraanurag-thakur-hate-speech-firs-against-bjp-leaders-6296121/). It was a typical argument by an advocate in a court. But his main point of contention, as summarized in the report itself was: 

Judiciary should have acted with greater alacrity in cases involving hate speech. Providing the government time to file FIRs “at an appropriate time” is deeply disturbing. The Court being the guardian of the Constitution and parens patriae of citizens of Delhi was bound to have acted with alacrity.

The context was the Delhi High Court acceding to the Centre’s argument that “the time was not conducive to file FIRs related to the alleged hate speeches as the priority right now is to ensure peace” and adjourning the hearing to as late as April 13. There was a snide remark about the transfer of judge Muralidhar of the said court too:

Coming on the heels of the questionable transfer of Justice S Muralidhar — his bench had ordered registration of FIRs on hate speeches within 24 hours — the division bench presided over by Chief Justice Patel ought to have handled the matter more carefully.

The learned advocate, as the judges would have addressed him, seems to have forgotten that long before the Delhi High Court judges did what they did, the apex court had adjourned as many as 60 petitions seeking to declare the Citizenship Amendment Act as illegal for as inordinately a period as the PIL against hate speeches had been adjourned by the Delhi High Court. And worse, the CAA had become law and it was not an event that was happening, it was an event that was over, even granting the CJI his excuse quoted earlier. 

Preceding the Indian Express article was a more reasoned article in the The Swarajya Magazine on 27 Feb 2020 (https://swarajyamag.com/politics/delhi-pays-for-indulgingshaheen-bagh-recalcitrance-not-just-police-and-netas-courts-too-responsible). The subtitle said it all:

Delhi Pays For Indulging Shaheen Bagh Recalcitrance; Not Just Police And Netas, Courts Too Responsible.

 The report added:

The Delhi communal riots, which could have easily been predicted after two-and-a-half months of Muslim-led protests over the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) 2019, which included blockage of arterial roads in the national capital and incendiary speeches against the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government that bordered on Hinduphobia, shows how the law and order system has rotted to the core.

I had commented on this article as follows:

Why Courts Too Responsible? In my view it is ONLY the courts that are responsible for the mayhem in the country today. They have dumped laws duly legislated by the competent body (National Commission for appointment of Judge Act), they have ordered FIRs against soldiers operating in insurgency prone areas under the Armed Forces Special Powers Act, when civilian death occurs, forcing 400 odd soldiers, including officers, to petition the court itself to clarify whether they should  obey their superiors or flaunt the court orders when confronted with anti-national elements; they order prosecution of police officers involved in maintaining law and order  when the law breakers are lawyers and victims are the police personnel themselves (as it happened in Delhi a few months ago and in Chennai High Court premises a few years ago). It is time that judges led actions against criminals from the front along with soldiers in internal security duties and police personnel in routine law and order maintenance.

To recapitulate, let us understand the basic tenets of jurisprudence. Three of them that comes to mind are:

- Your liberty ends where my nose begins - Justice delayed is justice denied and - Justice should not only be done but seen to be done.

That the apex court has been wavering in acknowledging the first tenet can easily be seen in the way it has handled litigation on bandhs/hartals and blocking roads. 

More than a decade or a decade and a half back it had upheld a verdict of the Kerala High Court holding bandhs illegal. I also remember a report in the media which informed the readers that the Mumbai High Court had penalized two political parties Rs 10 lakhs each for declaring a bandh in Mumbai after that. But bandhs have continued to disrupt normal life in Kerala even after that verdict. Only thing is they are being perpetrated in the name of hartals. 

Wanting to clear certain doubts I had sought the copies of the court orders from the Home Minister’s office in Kerala, under the RTI Act. The application was transferred to the Law Department, who in turn transferred it to the High Court itself. And horror of horrors, the High Court denied it claiming that the High Court rules forbade providing such information as it was part of judicial proceedings. 

Much later, the apex court had dismissed a petition questioning the declaration of a bandh in Tamil Nadu claiming that protesting was a democratic right and it could not be curbed. 

There is no doubt that the right to protest must be protected in a democracy. If nothing else, it is certainly serving as a safety valve to let up pent up emotions against injustice
being perpetrated by the government. But the important question that cannot be neglected is: why should someone protest in a manner that impinges on another citizen’s right not to protest on the issue? 

Despite failing to prevent the rights of most citizens to lead their lives in their routine manner being violated by some, the Kerala High Court issued another order- prohibiting public meetings on road sides. There being no venues earmarked for staging protests, the Kerala Government did the next best thing. In partial compliance with the court order they issued an order to regulate such meetings by necessitating the permission of the police for organizing them.  And what does the police do? They accept applications, would not give receipts or permission and allow the event to pass. And if there is trouble at the scene the organizers would have it. 

About justice being denied through denial, even the courts dare not deny it. But what we see is that the courts, read judges and advocates, only keep touting an irrelevant judge to population ratio (instead of a realistic judge to docket ratio) to palm off the blame to the Executive. They have done nothing about the tariq pe tariq (adjournments at the drop of a hat) syndrome that has become a joke among the public, or the colonial legacy of vacations that only the judiciary enjoys among public institutions even after 70 years of shedding off the yoke of slavery and the equally objectionable docket management. While the first two are self-explanatory, the last one may need some explanation. It is the procedure whereby 100s of cases are listed before every magistrate everyday and almost 90 percent of them are adjourned after mustering, that is checking the presence of the parties to the cases. 

No wonder Arundhati Roy had commented that the process in our courts is part of the punishment. Unfortunately, it is so not only for the accused (who as per law is deemed innocent till convicted finally) but also for the aggrieved/complainant/petitioner. But it was H D Shourie who had observed correctly that 'Lawyers are accused of employing delaying methods, but no lawyer can succeed if the court refuses an adjournment.' ('How long before justice comes?', The New Indian Express of 04 Dec 2004.)

Coming to the last issue of Justice being seen to be done, I must admit that such cases are becoming rarer if not extinct already. Does anybody remember any judgment that they understood to be fair and just? I do not. And that is from an observer of the performance of our judiciary for over two decades now. 

The judges always have the investigation officer, the prosecution etc to blame for their verdicts going awry. But let me ask one simple question: who is responsible for the failure of the judiciary to deliver justice in the case where a former Chief Justice of India decided that his office was not under the purview of the RTI Act? It had taken almost a decade before the apex court finally disposed of the case holding that the office of the CJI was within the purview of the Act. Who is responsible for the delay and who was the accused who was punished? We have heard of courts imposing stiff penalties on some litigants for wasting its time on ‘frivolous’ matters and dismissing their petitions. But no penalties in a case that dragged on for almost a decade in the apex court only? Just for the information of the uninitiated, the RTI Act provides for imposing a maximum penalty of Rs 25,000/- on a Public Information Officer who fails to provide the information sought even after 30 days @ Rs 250/- per day of delay. If the custodian fails to provide the information to the PIO, the Act has also declared the custodian as the PIO for imposing penalty. 

I had bought a book by the renowned jurist Fali S Nariman. It was the title that had lured me: 'India's Legal system: Can it be saved? Unfortunately, the internationally reputed lawyer disappointed me totally with no suggestions whatsoever to save our legal system. 

While I can publish a book on the quotes I have compiled about the judiciary it is my considered opinion that the failure of our judiciary has not only wreaked havoc with the rule of law in our country but it has also led to the failure of the other organs also in the matter of providing the services due to the public. Two relevant quotes are: 

Judges B. N. Agarwal and G. S Singhvi had suggested that "for the bureaucracy in the country to work without corruption, these bureaucrats need to be flogged."

Judges S. B. Sinha and Markandeya Katju, were more severe and had opined that "the only way to rid the country of corruption is to hang a few of you on the lamp post. The law does not permit us to do it but otherwise we would prefer to hang people like you at the lamppost … everywhere, we have corruption. Nothing is free from corruption. Everybody wants to loot this country. The only solution for this menace is to hang some people in the public so that it acts as a deterrent on others."

As an activist using the RTI Act extensively to realize the import of the law-to contain corruption and to hold Governments and their instrumentalities accountable to the governed, as set forth in its preamble- I can say for sure that if only I could have approached the courts to prosecute the information commissioners under Sec 219 of the Indian Penal Code most of the information commissioners would be behind bars not only for the rest of their lives but also for their next seven lives, @ seven years per wrong decision in a second appeal. But I dare not. Why? 

This is what the National Commission to review the working of the Constitution has reported: 

'Judicial system has not been able to meet even the modest expectations of the society.  Its delays and costs are frustrating, its processes slow and uncertain.  People are pushed to seek recourse to extra-legal methods for relief.  Trial system both on the civil and criminal side has utterly broken down.' Also, 'Thus we have arrived at a situation in the judicial administration where courts are deemed to exist for judges and lawyers and not for the public seeking justice'.

And this leads me to my worst fear. And that is the ever-widening schism between the public and public servants.  It is almost us (public) vs them (the public servants) and it certainly does not bode well for the future of the country. 

Tailpieces: 1. The apex court had promptly dismissed a petition seeking to declare CAA as legal with a snub that it was for the first time the court was confronted with a petition to declare a duly enacted law as legal. 2. In Kerala, a District Collector had charged a doctor under Sec 505 of IPC and 120 of the Kerala Police Act on a report by the District Medical Officer that the doctor had spoken on a visual media platform that she had reported about a suspected corona virus infected person to the ADMO and no action was taken by the department.

12 Mar 2020 

Law and the Layman


LAW AND THE LAYMAN
P M Ravindran, raviforjustice@gmail.com

Long before I had learnt during high school that judiciary is an organ of our Constitution and its task was to protect the citizens from executive excesses and also to sit in judgment over disputes between citizens, between citizens and the state, between states and between the states and the Centre I had been hearing from elders that it was a blessing to pass through this life without entering a police station or a court. Of course then one did not understand what they meant. And by the time one understood the frustration of the ordinary citizen at being denied even access to justice it has definitely been too late. The failure of the judiciary has totally corroded not only the ordinary citizen’s faith in the judiciary but even in the other organs of the Constitution-the Executive, Parliament/Legislatures and even the media.

Almost a decade back Transparency International had produced a survey report as part of their corruption index studies. It stated that while India figured as one of the most corrupt countries in the world the police and the judiciary took the cake for being the most corrupt. While one could swallow it hook, line and sinker what had bothered me was the pecking order-police and the judiciary. And that was when I did an evaluation through first principles and this is what I concluded.

Law makers without any prescribed qualities, qualifications or experience, their men Fridays (popularly known as bureaucrats, who are required to help them in decision making by collecting and collating data and maintaining records)  without any accountability and a judiciary which has the scope for the most whimsical decision making being held not only without accountability and beyond criticism but also protected by a totally illogical and weird armour called contempt of court, are the essential features of this Constitution in a nut shell.

Further, among the three organs of our Constitution the law-makers are controlled by the people (may not be substantially, but at least notionally through the ballots), bureaucracy (yes, bureaucracy, because without the active support of the bureaucracy no politician can do any wrong!) and finally the judiciary; the law-enforcers are also controlled by the law-makers (again may not be substantially but notionally through a transfer to an uncoveted post) and the judiciary. And then there are the eyes and ears of the people- the media waiting to sensationalize every news involving the misdemeanor of these authorities. In spite of such strict supervision and control all that we have been hearing has been about the politician-bureaucrat-underworld nexus even though the fact remains that none, worth the name, from this unholy nexus have ever been punished by the holier-than-thou judiciary. (Lalu Yadav spending most of his prison term in hospitals or Kanimozhi and Maran having spent some time as under trials in Tihar and now P Chidambaram and D K Sivakumar doing their time as under trials are recent developments.)

So now think of how bad a system can be which is not only NOT subject to supervision but also kept beyond critical observation. Well isn’t our judiciary just that? And do I need to recapitulate that quip: power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely?

The judiciary, by its own admission, is a failure on account of preposterous delays. And the only reason that judges and advocates, who support them, can tout for the delay is a fictitious judge to population ratio. This is on the face of it illogical because what matters is the number of cases filed and not the population. Thus it is the judge to docket ratio that matters and not judge to population ratio. Any judge or advocate who talks of judge to population ratio should be considered unfit for their jobs.

Worse, the judiciary is also a failure viewed from the principle that justice should not only be done but seen to be done.

This may not be obvious to the ordinary citizens normally. But even that pall of ignorance is getting dissipated. At least that is what the apex court verdict on demolishing the 5 flat complexes at Marad, Kochi, Kerala is proving. There are plenty of social media sites that have analysed and reported the judgment and the background. (I am leaving out the main stream media which is now vociferous on the issue but had never highlighted the issue at the right time.) 

One thing that stands out is that the victims, the flat owners, had never been heard by the courts. A message that was in circulation on Whatsapp by an advocate even blamed the owners for not becoming a party to the cases that had been disposed of by the courts. But, though unknowingly, he was himself admitting that the courts never made the victims parties to the cases that, we are to believe, were processed legally.

To recapitulate what had actually happened in Marad, here is the gist.

As per the Coastal Zone Regulations, the area where these flats had been constructed were in Zone 3 where no constructions were allowed. The then local government, a Panchayat, in 2005-6, gave permission to the developers for construction, either through ignorance of laws or due to corruption. (K A Devasia, president of Maradu panchayat between 2000 and 2005, said that out of five building permits for apartments, two had been issued before 2000.)

However, in another case, the High Court had observed around the same time, that the Coastal Zone Mapping was ambiguous.

Subsequently the Panchayat was upgraded to a Municipality. And the vigilance team of the municipality noted some violations of the building permits and cancelled the permits.
In 2012, the matter reached the Kerala High Court which observed that permit holders cannot be taken to task for the failure of local authorities in complying with statutory provisions and notifications. (https://indianexpress.com/article/india/life-savings-put-in-flats-ordered-razed-these-kochi-residents-have-nowhere-to-go-5827203/)

Meanwhile some violations of the CZR were noted and the state government had directed the municipality to revoke all permits.  Accordingly the municipality issued a stop memo to the builders which was challenged in the High Court of Kerala and decided against the Municipality, reportedly on the ground that the state government had no authority to direct the local self government to act in a particular way. Appeal/ review petitions were also reportedly dismissed. (ToI, 09 May 2019)

The Coastal Zone Regulations Management Authority filed a SLP in the apex court. This time the tide changed. The apex court set up a three member committee-comprising the District Collector, the Secretary of the Municipality and another member- to clarify the status of the region with respect to the CZR.

The committee reported that as per the 1991 CZR notification and 1996 Kerala State Coastal Zone Management Plan 1996, the area was under CZR 3 and no construction was permitted within 200 meters of the high tide line. These flats were within this distance and hence needed to be demolished. What the committee did not report was the fact that Marad has been classified as Zone 2 as per the new CZR notification of 2011 which had been approved by the Union Government in Feb 2019.

Reports suggest that the court had ordered the committee to hear the affected parties also. While the committee had reported that none of the owners turned up before it, the owners maintain they were not heard. I would believe the owners unless it is proved that the committee had issued notices to the 350 affected owners and none of them had turned up. The onus is on the Committee and the bench that accepted their report whole heartedly to come clean on this.

Based on the report of the Committee, the division bench of judges Arun Mishra and Navin Sinha ordered on 8 May 2019 that the flats should be demolished within 30 days and report submitted to the court.

Reports also suggest that the order has stated that the owners could follow legal procedures for compensation from the developers. We have heard of putting the cart before the horse. Now we see it happening.

In the wake of the severe criticism of the judgment and protest, subsequently the court has ordered the (bankrupt) Govt of Kerala to pay Rs 25 lakhs each to the flat owners as interim compensation and to recover the amount from the developers and public servants who have colluded with them.

A retired high court judge has been appointed to process the claims of the owners seeking further compensation.

Meanwhile the social media is full of video reports on the subject. Many of the owners had bought these flats for prices ranging from Rs 4 lakhs to 10 lakhs as per registration documents, while it is common knowledge that they would cost between Rs 40 lakhs and 1.5 crores.  One owner who had posted on face book that he had bought his flat for Rs 60 lakhs is now reported by these investigative reporters to have bought it for less than 10 lakhs. John Britas, the media advisor to the CM of Kerala, also had reportedly brought his flat at a highly undervalued price!

I have tried to access the order at http://judis.nic.in but could only see three orders of Arun Mishra listed between 07 and 10 May 2019 and the judgment I sought was not there. It is to be noted that though the court proceedings are conducted in open courts, all orders are not published at their websites. Only orders approved as ‘Reportable’ are published.)

There was a report which stated that the order mentions an effort to bribe the judges too.
This again is a serious allegation which needs to be probed and taken to its logical end.

This allegation also reminds one of a similar allegation by the bench that heard the Jain Hawala case. Apart from the judge stating that there were threats to the bench no follow up action had been reported.

In another report Arun Misra had even got furious and asked whether the parties were trying to influence him by employing a Bengali advocate.

I have already expounded how the apex court judgment in the case of women’s entry in Sabarimala was a blatant violation of the Constitution itself. Readers may go through ‘Nero fiddled while Rome burnt…’ at http://www.vijayvaani.com/ArticleDisplay.aspx?aid=4849.

While it is becoming more and more difficult to discern a good verdict from our higher judiciary there can be plenty of examples for the wrong ones.

Pinarayi Vijayan, then CPM State Secretary, had announced a protest in front of the High Court, Kerala on 14 Nov 2011 (Mathrubhumi, 11 Nov 2011). The issue was that the High Court had called M V Jayarajan, one of the leaders of the party, a worm, while prosecuting him for contempt of court for stating that the judge who had banned road side meetings was a dimwit ('sumban' is the malayalam word used).

Jayarajan, who was sent to jail for six months, had reasons to make such a comment because the right to protest is considered a democratic right and held as sacrosanct as a fundamental right itself. This had been clarified by the apex court when a bandh was declared in Tamil Nadu in support of the Tamils in Sri Lanka.

Incidentally, the same apex court had earlier upheld an order of the High Court of Kerala banning bandhs. The pity is that the same bandh continued to be perpetrated subsequently by changing its nomenclature to hartal.

My effort to get copies of these orders from the Home Ministry failed because it was forwarded to the Law Ministry and further to the High Court itself who denied the copies on the ground that the Kerala High Court RTI Rules had exempted information related to judicial proceedings from the purview of the RTI Act.

Thus the confusion remains whether it was the action that led to the shutdown of normal life on calls for bandhs that was banned or merely the reference to those actions as bandh.

There was another confounding order of the apex court reported in the Mathrubhumi of 08 Feb 2018. It was regarding compensation in the case of vehicles which have been sold but not yet transferred to the new owner as per the registration certificate.

The case started with a MACT holding that the owner, as per the registration certificate, was as much responsible as the driver. The Kerala High Court rightly cancelled the order stating that when there was proof of transfer of the vehicle, the seller cannot be held responsible for what happens after the sale. It was this logical order that was turned on its head by the apex court.

For those not conversant with the procedure followed with transfer of vehicle ownership it is like this.

On payment of the agreed cost, the seller hands over the vehicle to the buyer along with all the documents, viz RC, Insurance Certificate, PUC Certificate, Form 29 (Notice of Transfer of Ownership of a Motor Vehicle as prescribed in the Motor Vehicle Act) and a Delivery Note indicating the date and time of handing over. Apart from the original of the Delivery Note all that the seller would have in his possession could be copies of the certificates and Form 29. It is the responsibility of the buyer to produce the vehicle before the Registering Authority, present the papers and get the re-registration done in his name. It should be as clear as daylight that the seller has no control over the vehicle or the buyer after the Delivery Note has been signed and vehicle taken possession by the buyer.

It needs to be clarified that Form 29 mandates that the transferor (seller) send this Form 29 to the Registering Authority where the transferee (buyer) resides in duplicate and a copy to the Registering Authority where it is already registered. The Registering Authority of the buyer is required to return one copy to the seller as soon as the transfer is recorded by them. But this procedure is not followed in practice. Even when the seller makes sure that he complies with this requirement, in addition to giving additional copies to the buyer, there is nothing he can do till the seller produces the vehicle before the Registering Authority and completes the formalities and gets the re-registration done in his name. Even then the Registering Authority never ever bothers to convey the transfer details to the seller.

When the buyer has to register the vehicle with a different registering authority there is another form, Form 28, for getting a No Objection Certificate, from the registering authority where the seller had registered it. (This has now been done away by the latest amendments)

We also saw how the Vishakha guidelines, on sexual harassment in work places, of the apex court, was violated by the apex court itself in the matter of an allegation against the CJI himself.

In 1997, the Supreme Court had noted that “the present civil and penal laws in India do not adequately provide for specific protection of women from sexual harassment in work places”, and laid down the ‘Vishakha Guidelines’ (Vishakha & Ors vs State Of Rajasthan & Ors). Sixteen years later, Parliament enacted The Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013.

The Supreme Court has a Gender Sensitisation and Internal Complaints Committee headed by a woman judge, with a majority of woman members. The committee has a laid-down procedure for dealing with complaints of sexual harassment on the premises of the court. But it has no power to deal with complaints against the CJI or judges. In respect of misconduct by judges, the in-house process can be initiated only by the CJI. The Regulations are silent on a situation where the allegation is against the CJI himself.

Whither ‘be thou ever so high the law is above you’?

In an order dated 26 Nov 2010 an apex court bench had made some adverse comments about the Allahabad High Court which was challenged through a Special Leave Petition (31797 of 2010). One such observation was about relations of judges practicing in the court and misusing their positions-“We do not mean to say that all lawyers who have close relations as Judges of the High Court are misusing that relationship.  Some are scrupulously taking care that no one should lift a finger on this account.  However, others are shamelessly taking advantage of this relationship”. Defending this observation the bench of judges Markandeya Katju and Gyan Sudha Misra made another great observation:  the reputation of an institution is damaged and its image sullied when some of its members pass shocking orders and behave in a totally unacceptable manner.

More than a decade and a half back Binod Kumar Roy, Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, had identified this problem and he had issued an administrative directive wherein he had identified a dozen judges whose relatives were advocates and forbade them from appearing before any of these 12 judges. This ensured that a judge cannot help even a fellow judge's kin. Within a month of this directive, the SC collegium recommended his transfer to the Patna High Court. (See ‘All in the Family’ and ‘Judge Dread’ at https://www.outlookindia.com/magazine/story/all-in-the-family/225626 and http://www.outlookindia.com/article/Judge-Dread/225624 both published on 08 Nov 2004)

In C Ravichandran Iyer vs Justice A M Bhattacharjee & Ors (1995), the Supreme Court said ‘misbehaviour’ could not have a straitjacketed definition. But if the conduct of a judge leads to the credibility of the judiciary being called into question, it should be considered misbehaviour. Misconduct prior to assuming office is not exempt. In 2009, Rajya Sabha had passed an impeachment motion against Justice Soumitra Sen of Calcutta High Court for allegedly misappropriating funds several years before he became a judge. Sen tendered his resignation and escaped punitive action under the laws for the actual crime he had prima facie committed; because, before Parliament set the impeachment procedure rolling the allegations would have been investigated by a committee of the senior most judges of the apex court and given the green signal.

Even impeachment is not a criminal trial. In all civil matters, the standard of proof is the “preponderance of probabilities”. In Australia and South Africa, this is the standard of proof in the impeachment process of judges. India does not currently have a statutory mechanism to examine the misconduct of judges, and short of the complex process of impeachment, there is no mechanism available to make judges accountable.

Arun Shourie, while releasing his book ‘Courts and their Judgments’, had made a tongue in cheek comment. He had said that there was a need to have a group of eminent persons to study important judgments of the higher courts so that the judges were aware that their decisions would be subjected to scrutiny and that could act as a deterrent for whimsical conduct.

As an activist in the field of Right to Information the order, dated 17 Sep 2019, of Deepak Gupta, judge of the apex court, in a series of civil appeals (16 of them, to be precise, Civil appeals numbers 9828, 9844, 9845, 9846-57 and 9860, all of 2013), on the issue of substantial financing amused me a lot. ‘Substantially financed by the government’ is a factor used to determine if a private entity is a public authority or not, as only public authorities come under the purview of the RTI Act, 2005. In paras 26-27 of the order he states:
26. In our view, ‘substantial’ means a large portion. It does not necessarily have to mean a major portion or more than 50%. No hard and fast rule can be laid down in this regard. Substantial financing can be both direct or indirect…..

27. Whether an NGO or body is substantially financed by the government is a question of fact which has to be determined on the facts of each case. There may be cases where the finance is more than 50% but still may not be called substantially financed. Supposing a small NGO which has a total capital of Rs.10,000/ gets a grant of Rs.5,000/ from the Government, though this grant may be 50%, it cannot be termed to be substantial contribution. On the other hand, if a body or an NGO gets hundreds of crores of rupees as grant but that amount is less than 50%, the same can still be termed to be substantially financed.

However, para 29 of the order states:

29. While interpreting the provisions of the Act and while deciding what is substantial finance one has to keep in mind the provisions of the Act. This Act was enacted with the purpose of bringing transparency in public dealings and probity in public life. If NGOs or
other bodies get substantial finance from the Government, we find no reason why any citizen cannot ask for information to find out whether his/her money which has been given to an NGO or any other body is being used for the requisite purpose or not.

Given the simplicity of this argument doesn’t it make the earlier questions of substantial financing becoming redundant? To my mind it does. But then there is another problem that arises. It is regarding the question ‘why any citizen cannot ask for information to find out whether his/her money which has been given to an NGO or any other body is being used for the requisite purpose or not?’ Specifically it is about the ‘his/her’ money part of it.  To take an analogy, does the share holder of a company have the right to know only on how his shares are used by the company or the overall performance of the company?   

The subversion of the RTI Act by the information commissioners, as evident in their decisions, could be a classic study to prove my contention that it is the failure of the judiciary that has encouraged public servants to flout laws and be corrupt and treacherous. I am not dwelling on this subject anymore here because it has been covered sufficiently in a series of five articles titled ‘RTI: Exposing the traitors among public servants’ published on 27 Mar 2018 at http://www.vijayvaani.com/ArticleDisplay.aspx?aid=4626 and the next four days.

I am also reminded of the Air India flight crash at Mangalore almost a decade back. All those who had died were to be paid equal compensation. But the insurance companies took up the matter with the apex court which directed that compensation needed to be paid only proportionate to the income of the victims. I am still wondering how could the income of the victims be made a factor in deciding the compensation as all of them had brought the tickets paying the same fare (except for the different classes) And an equal share from the fare would have gone to finance the insurance policy under which the compensations were being paid.

After 70 years of independence we heard for the first time of some public servants from the Income Tax and Customs and Central Excise departments being forced to retire for alleged incompetence or corruption. This was done, reportedly, under the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules.

However Sections 217 to 219 of the Indian Penal Code which provide for punishing public servants who disobey direction of law, who falsify documents etc with upto 7 years of imprisonment have never been used to clean the system of the corrupt and treacherous  public servants.

Right now there is a raging controversy about a flyover constructed at a cost of about 48 crores in 2016 having given away and closed to traffic in 2018. The Vigilance Department investigating the case had recently arrested the then Secretary of the Public Works Department, T O Sooraj and based on his statements the investigating team was about to arrest the then minister Ibrahim Kunju and Mohammed Hanish, then MD of Kerala Roads and Bridges Development Corporation. Reports suggest that this move has been stayed unofficially through political intervention.

Incidentally, T O Sooraj has been controversial since 2003 with allegations that he did not correctly handle the Marad beach massacre (a communal riot where 8 hindus were killed by a muslim mob on 02 May 2003) when he had been the District Collector in Kozhikode. (Read more details at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marad_massacre) His home and properties were raided in 2015 when Ramesh Chennithala of the Congress had been the Home Minister. But Sooraj’s links with Muslim League had thwarted all efforts to bring him before the law till now. He had retired with pension in 2018. Interestingly, his name figures in the list of the 10 most corrupt members of the IAS (https://starsunfolded.com/list-of-most-corrupt-ias-officers-in-india)

The current arrest is said to be a bid to bring the opposition to the bargaining table and stop them from making an issue of corruption in Kannur International Airport Limited (KIAL) and Kerala Infrastructure Investment Fund Board (KIIFB). It is reported that the government is preventing the CAG from auditing these institutions due to massive misuse of power and corruption.

This is not an isolated act indicating the politician-bureaucrat nexus.

In an article ‘How the IAS has let India down’ NC Saxena, a former bureaucrat has written about how he had to ‘bribe’ a Chief Minister. (https://www.hindustantimes.com/analysis/how-the-ias-has-let-india-down/story-3yZW0jUi2jmMMrvcg8VCMN.html) He claims that his book, What Ails the IAS and Why It Fails to Deliver, describes how reforms initiated failed to make any impact because most IAS officers resist change, or are indifferent to the poor. I may correct him on the last part. They are not indifferent merely to the poor but everybody who are not involved in helping them in their career or amassing wealth. Exceptions no doubt are there.

Kerala, particularly, seems to be the breeding ground of corruption and abuse of office. A case of stabbing a student at University College, Thiruvananthapuram has disturbed a virtual hornet’s nest. Even recruitment to police, done through Kerala PSC, has been exposed as being influenced by the political party in power. It also exposed another fact- the KPSC has 21 members catering to just about 3 crore population against the UPSC which has only 11 members. The cost to exchequer of a KPSC member is estimated to be Rs 78 lakhs per annum.

The ministers in Kerala have 25 members as personal staff (reduced from 30 of the previous government) whose job is not defined and are employed as per choice of the minister.  These employees even become eligible for pension after two and a half years of employment. That is a minister, during just one tenure, can arrange to have 50 kith and kin enjoying pension for the rest of their lives. We had the case of P K Sreemati, then Health Minister, employing her own daughter in law as an official cook.

It is pertinent to mention here that on taking over as PM for the first time, Narendra Modi had limited the personal staff of union ministers to just 15.

The Chief Minister of Kerala has also created a record of sorts for having the most number of advisors, some of them even conferred with cabinet rank and the pay and perks that go with it. One of his lieutenants, Sampath, who lost the last elections to the Lok Sabha, has been rehabilitated with cabinet status at Kerala House, New Delhi, apparently for liaison with the Union Government.

It would be unfair if I give the impression that the government in Kerala is the only rotten apple in the basket.

When Lalu Prasad Yadav was the Railway Minister, the railways introduced a side middle berth in all sleeper coaches, just for increasing the capacity. This was done without any proper study or evaluation and had to be discarded due to public protest. But the damage had been done. 5120 coaches had been retrofitted at a cost of Rs 1.25 lakh for an AC 3 T Coach and Rs 1.3 lakhs for a Sleeper Coach by 31 Jan 2009. The cost of removing these additional berths was not available. Curiously Garib Rath Expresses, originally designed with 3rd side berth continue to be used even now. This fact has been included here just to highlight how the synergy required between various functionaries of our government is missing and the cost the tax payer has to pay for it.

Ultimately, the question that one would like to ask is why are public servants not held responsible for their crimes of omissions and commissions? And why should allegations of crime against public servants of a state government allowed to be investigated and prosecuted by the same State’s investigating and prosecuting agencies? The analogy is the same as kins of judges appearing in their courts as has been explained earlier.

Just to highlight the impunity with which public servants work brainlessly and arrogantly, here is the example of the E K Majhi, Principal Secretary to the Government of Kerala. He has issued a circular on 16 Jul 2015 directing all government offices to issue receipts to the public whenever they submit any document to the office. The absurdity is that the receipt is required to be given within one week. The preposterousness is that he has quoted two earlier circulars –dated 12 Jan 2009 and 20 Sep 2011- on the same subject which mandated that the receipts be issued immediately. The circular of 2009 had given not only the format of the receipt but also the size of a board to display the information, including the format of the receipt, for the consumption of the public. The 2011 circular had reiterated the contents of the 2009 circular. The matter has been brought to the notice of the Chief Secretary and the Governor.

I would prefer to believe that there are still enough serious citizens interested in the rule of law who would have lent their shoulders to make our systems deliver if only….our courts provided an iota of hope that their efforts would not be merely waste of time, energy and resources.


03 Oct 2019